Jeff Arcuri Wife Katie Thurston Has Stage 4 Cancer, and Plenty of the Jokes Are Hers

The former “Bachelorette” star married the comedian five weeks after her breast cancer diagnosis, and he turned the year that followed into his first Netflix special.

Katie Thurston got the call that she had breast cancer on Feb. 13, 2025, while she and her fiancรฉ, comedian Jeff Arcuri, were in Hawaii. He had a show that night, and he went on.

“He had to pretend everything was alright while in reality, I was crying in the green room thinking what our next steps would be,” Thurston wrote on Instagram almost a year later.

They married five weeks after that call, at home in New York. Less than a week after the wedding, she found out the cancer had spread to her liver.

Nineteen months later, Thurston, 35, and Arcuri, 38, are still married, and she is still in treatment. She had a double mastectomy in April, and the results of a liver biopsy she had in July have not been reported. Arcuri made their year the second half of his first Netflix special, “Nice to Meet You.” At home, plenty of the jokes about her cancer come from her.



How Jeff Arcuri met Katie Thurston

Thurston grew up outside Seattle and worked as a bank marketing manager before joining Matt James’ season of “The Bachelor” in 2021. She led Season 17 of “The Bachelorette” later that year and went on to build a career as a social media influencer. Her Instagram bio now calls her a breast cancer “thriver” and advocate.

In early 2024, while trying stand-up on the side, she came across Arcuri’s crowd-work videos. “I had a crush on him from afar,” she told People in February 2026. “Jeff is so charming, a little giggly and bashful. I remember texting my friends and being like, ‘This is my future husband.'”

Arcuri, who grew up in Monroe, Michigan, has been doing stand-up since around 2009. The two got to know each other by phone and met in person in May 2024. That August, he proposed on a beach in Hawaii. “My knees buckled!” she said.

A wedding moved up for treatment

Doctors in Los Angeles first diagnosed Stage 3 cancer and wanted her to start chemotherapy right away. Thurston moved to New York, where Arcuri lived, and he rescheduled tour dates to be with her.

The wedding was his idea. One night, Thurston told ABC News, he said, “I want to show you that I still love you and that I’m here to stay. I’ll get married to you tomorrow.”

They married on March 22, 2025, in the living room of the apartment they had just found. Their parents flew in from Michigan and Washington State. Arcuri told Deadline in July that he now thinks of it as the best day, because loving her was “the only sure thing I had in my life in the moment.”

What the tests showed next

Days after the wedding, a PET scan done for a clinical trial in New York found cancer in her liver. That made it Stage 4, also called metastatic breast cancer, which means it had spread beyond the breast. Doctors can treat it, but they do not consider it curable.

Further testing changed her treatment plan. The Los Angeles results had identified her cancer as HER2-positive, a type that would have meant starting chemo immediately. New pathology showed it was HER2-negative. For her kind of cancer, IV chemotherapy “is not the most effective first treatment,” her New York oncologist, Dr. Julia McGuinness, told People.

Her first chemo session, set for April 4, 2025, was called off. She started on daily pills that target the cancer and regular shots to suppress estrogen, which put her into early menopause at 34.

Plenty of the jokes are hers

“We’ve definitely cried a lot, but more at the beginning,” Thurston said in her February interview. “Now we’re just making really dark, shocking jokes.” When Arcuri can’t decide whether he wants dessert, she tells him, “Babe, I’m dying. I have cancer!”

Arcuri told Fox News about the night she handed him Lactaid at dinner after he left his in his hotel room. He thanked her and called her his angel, and she answered, “Don’t call me that, I ain’t dead yet.” His father spat out his food.

She shapes his act, too. Arcuri told People in September that she will stop him mid-conversation to tell him to write a line down, and that he has called her minutes before a big set to ask how one of his own bits goes. “She’s my muse in so many ways,” he said.

Thurston wrote on Instagram that the special, taped in Phoenix in December 2025, was filmed “during the hardest year of our lives,” and before it premiered on July 7, she told fans to stay through the credits, where “you might even see me telling a joke.”

Arcuri has been just as open about the fear. He told Fox that therapy helped him get through the year, and that he eventually admitted to Thurston he was afraid for her and sometimes pretended to be stronger than he was. She thanked him for saying it.

How is Jeff Arcuri’s wife doing now?

Thurston is alive and posting regularly. In March 2026 she warned that bot accounts might claim she had died and wrote, “I am not.” In mid-September she shared a video about a cosmetic procedure she had days earlier, the first surgery she chose for herself after more than a year of operations she needed.

The biggest unknown is her liver. Since January 2026, high liver enzymes have forced her to pause Kisqali, one of her cancer drugs, more than once. A scan in June showed no evidence of cancer in her liver, but the enzymes stayed high and her doctors couldn’t explain why. She had a liver biopsy in late July, and the results have not been reported.

On April 23 she played her last volleyball game before surgery, in a sport she has played since she was 11. “When I think of my double mastectomy, I don’t think of my changing appearance but instead my love for volleyball,” she wrote that night.

Six days later, surgeons in San Francisco removed the tissue from both breasts and placed implants in the same operation. She also chose nerve preservation, in the hope of getting back feeling over time.

“My amazing husband … continues to love me softly and gently and be by my side through this chapter.”

Katie Thurston on Instagram, May 2026

She has said she refuses to call her cancer a terminal illness.

Are Katie Thurston and Jeff Arcuri still together?

They are still married. In April 2026, a fake post claimed they had split. Thurston answered with a video asking Arcuri whether he was leaving her because he had stopped liking her posts. He told her he doesn’t “like” anything on Instagram. The next day, April 22, she announced they had bought a house.

A Brooklyn fixer-upper and plans for a family

The house is a three-story Victorian in Brooklyn, more than a century old, and the couple is documenting the renovation in a YouTube series called “The Fixer Upper.” Thurston said it felt like “a really good compromise,” close enough for Arcuri to get to the Comedy Cellar and far enough out for birds in the yard and a driveway.

An inspection found asbestos throughout the house. In July, Arcuri said the renovation, first expected to take about four months, was looking more like 18, and the couple was still living in Manhattan.

They don’t have children yet. They have two frozen embryos, both girls, from fertility treatment Thurston went through before her cancer treatment began. She said in an August Instagram video that she can no longer carry a child herself, so they would need a surrogate. Arcuri wants the house finished first, or as he put it on Kaitlyn Bristowe’s podcast in July, “a home for my baby before a baby for my home.”

Thurston has a shorter timeline in mind. The day before Arcuri spoke to People for its Sept. 14 story, she asked him, “Do you think maybe we could look into the surrogacy thing this year?”

He told People his reply was, “You just told me we’re doing too much!” He added, “Yes, our plates are full, but we made a lot of food on that plate.”

Timeline

DateWhat happened
Feb. 13, 2025Thurston was diagnosed with breast cancer
March 22, 2025They married at home in New York
March 28, 2025She announced the cancer was Stage 4
April 4, 2025Her planned chemo was called off after retesting
April 29, 2026She had a double mastectomy
July 7, 2026“Nice to Meet You” premiered on Netflix
Sept. 14, 2026Arcuri told People they are discussing surrogacy

This story draws on interviews Thurston and Arcuri gave to People, ABC News, Deadline, Fox News and Kaitlyn Bristowe’s podcast, along with Thurston’s Instagram posts and YouTube series.

Mary Green
Mary Greenhttps://thenotabledaily.com/
Mary C. Green is a journalist at The Notable Daily, where she covers celebrity news and entertainment. A Stanford graduate with more than three years in the field, she leads the site's editorial team and also reports on general news.

Similar Articles

Comments

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular